Catholic flux

Catholics Come Home

Remember before when I blogged about the Catholic Church not advertising? Well, it seems a Catholic organisation out there called “Catholics Come Home” agrees and has started producing some very nice videos. The following is amazing, it really makes me proud to be a Catholic.

I particularly love the line “For centuries we have prayed for you, and our world, every hour of every day” – I’ve never thought about it but as a collective body the Catholic Church is locked in prayer with God. There are so many of us that at any one point we (as an institution) are praying, which is a really lovely thought.

Labels: , ,

  • Created
    6.10.09
  • Author
    Lincoln Harper
  • Reaction
    0 comments
  • Link 
    Permalink
  • Share
    Bookmark and Share

Archbishop Vincent Nichols on social networking

Vincent Nichols

A few weeks ago the new Archbishop of Westminster, Vincent Nichols, commented on the usage of social networking amongst young people. I deliberately held my tongue in order to see how the debate would pan out. I’ve summarised a few of the best comments from the blogosphere below…

Vincent

Archbishop Vincent Nichols (link)

I think there's a worry that an excessive use or an almost exclusive use of text and emails means that as a society we're losing some of the ability to build interpersonal communication that's necessary for living together and building a community.

We're losing social skills, the human interaction skills, how to read a person's mood, to read their body language, how to be patient until the moment is right to make or press a point.

Too much exclusive use of electronic information dehumanises what is a very, very important part of community life and living together.

Facebook and MySpace might contribute towards communities, but I'm wary about it. It's not rounded communication so it won't build a rounded community.

If we mean by community a genuine growing together and a mutual sharing in an interest that is of some significance then it needs more than Facebook.

Among young people often a key factor in them committing suicide is the trauma of transient relationships.

They throw themselves into a friendship or network of friendships, then it collapses and they're desolate.

It's an all or nothing syndrome that you have to have in an attempt to shore up an identity; a collection of friends about whom you can talk and even boast.

But friendship is not a commodity, friendship is something that is hard work and enduring when it's right.

Biz Stone

Biz Stone (link)

I think it's kind of silly, anyone who says that isn't really familiar with the service because it's about humans connecting with each other and often in ways that they couldn't otherwise and it's the opposite of dehumanizing as far as I'm concerned.

Everything on the internet and in technology is built on other stuff and we stood on the shoulders of giants in many ways but Twitter adds a nuance and a new sense of connectivity that is pretty unique.

I don't think it's false, necessarily, people are using technology to communicate, it's not any less real than using the telephone to communicate.

Blake

Jonathon Blake (link)

So the Archbishop of Westminster warns about the dangers of electronic isolation and relationships mediated through the keyboard. Of course there are dangers and wise parents and balanced adults will guard against them.

However, there are greater dangers to relationships perhaps in Roman Catholicism. I have counselled those heartbroken that a member of their family had been snatched from them into a closed order of Nuns, others sucked into the loneliness of the celibate priesthood, many more isolated into religious fanaticism, others damaged by the homophobia, authoritarianism and sexism enshrined in church policy.

Religious bigotry has fuelled the fragmentation of societies, the increase in prejudice and reactionary thinking. Strange, because the Sacrament of the Mass is all about Holy Communication.

So when Facebook and other social networking sites allow people to communicate, to reconnect, to discover the thrill of friendships and to provide the resources to maintain them and explore them perhaps the church should be encouraging and supportive.

David Aaronovitch

David Aaronovitch (link)

The Archbishop of Westminster is just the latest in a long line of pessimists to be bewildered by a younger generation.

We’re only doomed if we want to be, and it isn’t Facebook, TV or Pop Idol that constitutes the greatest threat to the mental and social health of our teenagers, but rather the determined — almost ruthless — cultural pessimism of some of their spiritual, academic and commentating elders.

Shane Richmond

Shane Richmond (link)

Vincent Nichols' views are alarmist, ill-informed and unhelpful.

He seems to be under the impression that social networking sites are replacing other forms of communication. Nobody has said that we’re going to use the internet instead of real life. The internet makes it easier to stay in touch with people when you can’t be with them in person. It enriches communication, it doesn’t destroy it.

Vincent Nichols is mistaking social problems for technological ones. Still, not every Catholic agrees with him. Even the Pope is social networking.

Jonathan Wynne-Jones

Jonathan Wynne-Jones (link)

If the archbishop was concerned about the decline of personal communications and the impact of this on society, maybe he should also be worried about the apparent inability of people to read. Or maybe it’s just an inability to get past prejudice and overcome intolerance.

If people actually bothered to read the story and read the quotes they would see that the archbishop actually has an impressive grasp of modern culture and cares deeply about its future.

Nowhere does he actually attack these websites, rather he acknowledges - rightly - that for most people they can help build a community, if not a fully rounded one.

Much of the criticism of Nichols derives from a hostility to the Church and a drive to have its leaders’ pronouncement pushed from the public square, no matter how pertinent their comments are. Some also no doubt comes from those who are addicted to these sites and don’t want to face the facts.

George Pitcher

George Pitcher (link)

Archbishop Nichols does have a strong, broader point about the dehumanising effects of online communication. And not only among the young. We are all, frankly, in danger now of conducting human relationships almost exclusively through the prism of a computer screen.

Clearly a marriage, or parental responsibilities, cannot effectively (or enjoyably) be run by email and texting, though I have seen some who try. But it's at the professional and occupational level that I see the most insidious, creeping dehumanisation of technology.

You want to reach one of your household utilities? There's a website. Want to report something to the local council? Type it in the box. Note also that the "Contact us" page of most institutional websites usually never has a phone number.

What Archbishop Nicols [sic], who I notice makes himself personally available whenever he can, has pointed up is that the internet, with all its talk of "connectivity", was meant to bring the world together. Actually, it's driving us apart.

Alberto Contri

Alberto Contri (link)

There is no doubt that the birth of the Web has been the really big media revolution of the last century. It is equally true that the various applications that have been created search engine to social networking are radically changing the way we study, work, have fun, and socialize. In a word, they are changing the way we live.

When asked whether society is ready to absorb and manage such a change, it seems true that we must say no. And the aphorism of McLuhan "the medium is the message" is becoming a very bitter prophecy. The first internet bubble shows that platoons of managers have invested in crazy expectations of technological developments without asking questions about what content they should carry and why. Millions of people buy phones, increasing the performance of multimedia activities with increasingly poor phone connections; and the population, especially young people, has earned more than others from the visually apparent game of technology, while they are increasingly unaware of the research on any quality content. Tens of thousands of marketing managers have squandered nights on Second Life, forgetting that in nature nothing is created and nothing is destroyed, and that what is virtual is not real and therefore does not exist.

For Archbishop Nichols where one of the most efficient means of interactive communication triumphs, the content of communication has become so invalid or nonexistent, that, paradoxically, people are increasingly alone. And because loneliness is certainly one of the contributory causes of suicide, the excess of virtuality, with its fake friends, unreal or surreal, in the end may be an exasperating cause of loneliness.

My thoughts

First, it’s great that we have an Archbishop who gets social networking and the Internet. I’ve previously posted about how the Vatican needs to get with the times and update Vatican.va, harnessing the power of the Internet to connect with the millions of Catholics out there. In fact, I think he needs to get more involved by signing up for twitter; it’s really helped ordinary people connect with the PM, why not our spiritual leader in Britain?

Second, it’s clear that Vincent Nichols gets that some young people can be add-crazy on Facebook, adding anyone and anyone who they might know or want to know. There is a culture of “add-like-you’re-mad” in some young people, check out this genuine screenshot of one of my friend’s friends:

4990 friends on Facebook!

He’s simply saying that quantity is no substitute for quality, and he’s right. I have around 100 Facebook friends; around half are old friends from school and family and the other half are people I interact with on a day-to-day basis. I don’t think many people realistically know more people than that. In the example above, the guy has almost 5000 friends. Seriously, how does that work?

Facebook and social networking should be a supplement, not an alternative, to face-to-face communication.

Labels: , ,

  • Created
    18.8.09
  • Author
    Lincoln Harper
  • Reaction
    0 comments
  • Link 
    Permalink
  • Share
    Bookmark and Share

The Blessed Virgin Mary is on Facebook

BVM on Facebook

Seems like everyone who’s anyone is on Facebook these days, even the Blessed Virgin Mary. The social networking service, which claims to have 200 million active users, allows you to become a ‘fan’ of products and services, usually things like Coca-Cola. Some thoughtful user has created a fan page for our Mother Most Holy.

You probably can’t see in the preview image above, but people around the world post to her page with their intentions in the same way we might light a candle at mass. It’s a really lovely use of technology in the twenty-first century. Here’s a few of people’s requests:

  • I love you Mary! Pray for us and always keep us close to Jesus.
  • Mother Mary I pray for the entire worlds economy and the families who have been effected affected by the crisis.
  • I am so glad you are here. You are so gracious to be everywhere for us. Your kindness and grace toward our humanity is tremendous.
  • Sub tuum praesidium confugimus, Sancta Dei Genetrix. Nostras deprecationes ne despicias in necessitatibus, sed a periculis cunctis libera nos semper, Virgo gloriosa et benedicta. Amen.

You can click through to view all of the petitions and messages for Our Lady.

She needs your help!

However, it’s not all great. At the start of May, an inconsiderate Facebook user published two images that are clearly offensive to Catholics. The first implies that our Mother Most Pure is some kind of slut and the second suggests that she didn’t have a Virgin Birth.

Abuse on the BVM's fan page

I really don’t like people who can’t laugh at themselves, sometimes you just have to chuckle at yourself if you’re a Catholic. Try explaining to a Protestant that you effectively eat God in the Eucharist – it’s a pretty funny situation. The thing is, these images aren’t in good taste, they’re just plain offensive and you can’t really laugh at them at all.

If you’re a Catholic Facebook user, please help us rid these images defiling her page. Visit the "Beloved Virgin Mary" fan page and click "just fans" on her wall. Scroll down a bit and you'll find the offending images. Please click on "Report" to notify Facebook, choosing reason "attacks individual or group".

Report abuse dialogue

I’ve reported this before but it’s still online. Perhaps Facebook has a massive backlog of abuse cases to sort through and haven’t yet got to this one, or perhaps they just don’t think this image is offensive. I guess the only way to make them listen is if more people report abuse! Please, please, please report this attack on our Mother most Pure if you’re part of the Catholic Facebook community. And while you’re there, become a fan of her… she’s a cool lady.

Labels: ,

  • Created
    8.7.09
  • Author
    Lincoln Harper
  • Reaction
    0 comments
  • Link 
    Permalink
  • Share
    Bookmark and Share

Belief in evolution by country

So, this is quite interesting. From The Guardian:

The British Council has asked, with the help of Ipsos MORI, over ten thousand adults across ten countries from China to the USA, just what they think of evolution.

Findings in percent

  Heard of Darwin Agree evidence exists for evolution Think it is possible to believe in God and evolution
Argentina 86 44 62
China 90 55 39
Egypt 38 8 45
Great Britain 91 51 54
India 62 38 85
Mexico 91 52 65
Russia 93 39 54
South Africa 27 8 54
Spain 72 39 46
USA 84 33 53

The last column is the Catholic Church’s belief; that God and evolution can coexist. As the figures show, roughly half of the ten-thousand surveyed seem to agree.

You can view the other responses on this Google-hosted spreadsheet

Labels: ,

  • Created
    1.7.09
  • Author
    Lincoln Harper
  • Reaction
    0 comments
  • Link 
    Permalink
  • Share
    Bookmark and Share

Why doesn’t the Catholic Church advertise?

This post requires Adobe Flash Player. If you are viewing this article in a feed reader, you may need to visit the original post. Get Flash Player...

Okay, well perhaps not like that! Watching the clip above in The Simpsons the other day made me question why the Catholic Church doesn’t advertise. Things have changed, attending a Catholic Church is no longer just part of everyday life for many people. Indeed, people can walk past a Catholic Church just like a product on a shelf in a supermarket – unless Catholicism tells people why they should pop in, they’re gonna keep walking past. Companies advertise, perhaps Catholicism should.

What are we selling?

Ticket Afterlife insurance. Essentially, we’re marketing your ticket out of here and into heaven.

The problem? So is everyone else in our market. We need to work out what it is that makes Catholicism so special, what makes us different from the Muslims or Hindus… why people should be one of us and not one of them.

Not only that, we face increasing competition from within Christianity itself. The monopoly on Christ has passed and the church needs to deal with it. If people settle on a Christian way of life, what reason is there for them becoming a Catholic? Other denominations offer salvation through Christ at less of a cost. Catholic moral teaching is a lot more restrictive than that of some other Christian groups, for example the Church of England teaches that sex within marriage is an expression of physical love whereas Catholic teaching is that sex is only for procreation. Why should people give up sex for pleasure in order to achieve salvation, when our competitors are offering salvation with sex for pleasure?

The Catholic Church needs to work out why we’re the best and broadcast that to the world.

Atheism

Imagine if someone came along and started running adverts saying, “Actually, you don’t need washing powder… it’s all a sham”. The washing powder companies would be all over it, running adverts telling the public why they do need washing powder. It’s the same with religion, which is coming under fire from the atheists. Indeed, recently they started advertising…

bus

A tarnished reputation

When a product or brand is in trouble, what do they do? They advertise, advertise, advertise. They try to restore people’s confidence in their product. Look at McDonald’s, a few years ago they were facing allegations of making kids obese and causing environmental damage. Even today, their ad campaigns are focused on the ‘healthy’ carrot sticks and responsibly-sourced ingredients that they use. I have to say, I think it’s working – personally, I feel better about eating at McDonald’s now.

Recently, Catholicism has come into disrepute over physical, sexual and emotional abuse claims by the clergy on children. We absolutely should be using advertising to make this right – addressing the issues and answering people’s questions in order to regain trust (and therefore ‘customers’).

Is it right to advertise Catholicism?

For all of the reasons above, I think so. Moreover, other Christian denominations advertise – why shouldn’t we? I’ve always found His Holiness Benedict XVI’s speeches inspiring, but I only know about them because I’m Catholic. If we could get his message to the world through advertising, there’s endless possibilities.

Labels: , , ,

  • Created
    26.5.09
  • Author
    Lincoln Harper
  • Reaction
    0 comments
  • Link 
    Permalink
  • Share
    Bookmark and Share

Music for prayer and reflection

This post requires Adobe Flash Player. If you are viewing this article in a feed reader, you may need to visit the original post. Get Flash Player...

Music can be a great tool for getting you in the right frame of mind for prayer. In no particular order, here are four songs that I like. I’ve only used a small section of each song so as not to infringe on anyone’s copyright. If you’d like to buy from iTunes or Amazon there are links to do so.

Bread of Life - Boyce & Stanley

Buy from iTunes

Da pacem cordium - Taizé

Download for free from their site | Buy from iTunes | Buy from Amazon

Pie Jesu - All Angels

Buy from iTunes | Buy from Amazon

Ce matin-là - Air

Buy from iTunes | Buy from Amazon

My favourite of this bunch has to be the All Angels song. Either that or Air. Do you use music for prayer and reflection? If so, what are your favourite songs?

Labels: , ,

  • Created
    3.5.09
  • Author
    Lincoln Harper
  • Reaction
    0 comments
  • Link 
    Permalink
  • Share
    Bookmark and Share

Vatican.va is desperate for an update!

Every Catholic is familiar with the brown parchment background and tacky image based design – yep, it’s the Vatican online. Evokes a sort of nostalgia in us all, the world was a different place back when this first debuted.

The Vatican Website

However, whilst it may be familiar it is certainly not suited for purpose, or suited for the twenty-first century. You’re probably wondering why, after over a decade of putting up with the Vatican’s current design, I’m making a point now? Well, it was this image that struck a chord with me…

Vatican Obama-ified

Go ahead and click the image to visit; it works. It’s a play on the White House’s website after it’s Barack Obama redesign, a good example of web design how it should be done. You’re probably thinking “well, the White House website is for a country!” but let’s face it, Catholicism is like a country. Our capital is Vatican City, our head-of-state is Benedict XVI, our government ministers are the ordained folk and our citizens make up about one-fifth of the world’s population. Don’t forget, as well, that the Vatican exerts an enormous influence politically. When you look at it like that, we’re a much bigger country than the USA yet we have an awful website!

Now, I’m not saying that the Vatican needs to start offering Confessions online, I’m simply saying that we need a website that is fit-for-purpose. The current Vatican website aged quickly – they need a website that will stand the test of time.

Situations

To illustrate this point, let’s consider the following situations…

  • I’m a Catholic looking for information about St. Peter’s.
  • I’m a prospective Catholic, thinking of converting.
  • I’m a person who wants to follow updates.
  • I’m completing a project about Catholic attitudes towards euthanasia.

Catholic looking for information about St Peter’s

So, I’m going to the Holy See and want to get some information about St Peter’s Basilica. I hit up Vatican.va and click English. Lucky for me there’s a link on the homepage!

Link to St. Peter's Basilica

I click on it, and I’m taken to a site titled Basilica Papale di San Pietro – this is despite making the language choice English at the start of your visit. So, I hunt down an English button. The design of the site has completely changed so it takes a while but eventually I find it… It’s in Italian, but recognisable because I’ve studied a romance language.

Language link

Turns out, however, that I can’t click on it. There’s no hand, just a text select cursor. Clicking does nothing. emoticon_unhappy

So, I’ve wasted 10 minutes and I’ve not found out anything. Back to the homepage, in the bottom-left hand corner there’s another promising link…

Another link to St Peter's

I’m taken to a page that, again, looks different to the rest of the Vatican site and the page on St. Peter’s Basilica I’ve just visited – clear branding issues here. Anyway, there’s a link to St Peter’s but guess what…?

St Peter's link, not working

…it doesn’t work! I can’t click it.

Yet more time wasted, I’m leaving the Vatican.va website… I’ll look elsewhere. emoticon_unhappy

I’m a prospective Catholic, thinking of converting

At the moment, I’m non-religious, yet lately I’ve had a growing curiosity about Catholicism and I’d like to find out how I can ‘convert’. The most logical place to start is the Vatican website, I choose English as my language.

For a start, I’m a little confused about the abbreviations “W.Y.D” and “S.V.C” – I know nothing about Catholicism, don’t forget – but I carry on. I can’t see anything on the homepage about converting, so I think I’ll try the “New Search Engine” which has been ‘new’ for about ten years now.

The 'new' search engine

I search for “become Catholic”. The results don’t seem promising. “convert” – no; “join” – no, “baptism” – no. Hmm. What’s going on? Interestingly, the Vatican’s search is powered by Google Search Appliance meaning that it can handle some pretty advanced (normal language) queries. However, because the search box is so small on the homepage, I’m only entering one word queries.

N.B. I know that to become a Catholic, your first port of call should be your local Catholic Church. But this is the twenty-first century… people are workaholics, can they really find time? Not only that, but what if you’re not that into the idea of Catholicism to visit a church yet; you feel that you might be pressurised into joining there and just want to get some information on your terms. And, what if you just don’t know that you should visit a church first? What if you don’t know where your local church is, so you’re visiting the Vatican to find it? The Church of England’s website has a ‘church finder’.

The point here is that there’s no information at all; no page telling you to visit your local church. I’ll look elsewhere. emoticon_unhappy

I want to follow updates

Like many people today, I’ve a feed reader full of interesting news stories and I’d love to have the Pope in there. (Self-promotion: you can put Catholic Flux in your feed reader today by subscribing for free!) What I’d really like is something that allows me to follow the movements of the Holy Father; who he’s meeting, what he’s doing, where he’s going? Number10.gov.uk is really good for this, it lets you see what the PM’s up to in his daily duties. My only complaint is that it’s updated a little too frequently for my liking. But yeah, that’s for a different blog post. emoticon_tongue

I start my quest at Vatican.va in English, as before. There’s a link on the homepage for Latest Updates, that’s just what I’m looking for! emoticon_surprised

Latest Updates

But, when I get there I’m presented with a list of boring updates. No pictures, no videos… just text. This is despite the Vatican having Photo.va and their own YouTube channel. Not only that, I can’t see the familiar orange feed icon Feed icon in my title bar or anywhere on the page. I’ll look elsewhere. emoticon_unhappy

facebookI’m completing a project about Catholic attitudes towards euthanasia

In this case, I’ve actually found what I was looking for because I knew what I was looking for – the Catechism of the Catholic Church. I’ve found a passage in there that I’d like to share it with my classmates on Facebook who are having trouble. A share button, like the one to the left hand side of this blog post, would go down a treat. I’ll have to leave the Vatican website, to open Facebook, to give my classmates the link. emoticon_unhappy

What have we learnt from this?

All of the four situations above led to the user ultimately leaving the Vatican site to find their information (or interact with others) elsewhere. You might be wondering what is wrong this? The Vatican.va site should be the most authoritative site on the Internet for Catholicism resources. It’s not good enough to have people searching elsewhere, because anyone could publish anything online and say “this is what the Catholic Church says”.

Moreover, this is the age of the Internet. Get with the times, please, Benedict! It is a great tool for communication, which the Church could really exploit for promoting the message of Christ throughout the world. Alas, they do not.

Unfortunately, I can’t see anything being done about it soon. I think the only thing we can do is pray. emoticon_tongue

Labels: ,

  • Created
    2.5.09
  • Author
    Lincoln Harper
  • Reaction
    0 comments
  • Link 
    Permalink
  • Share
    Bookmark and Share

Notable

Guide

Catholicism vs. Christianity

Review

In the media

Prayer intentions

Vatican.va

Vatican.va desperately needs to be updated

Methods for personal prayer »

We're all taught what to pray, but often how to pray is forgotten.

In this guide we'll explore ways that you can pray in your every day life.

The authority of the bible »

Catholicism and other Christian denominations are divided by lots of things, but arguably the most important is the role and nature of the bible.

Brother Sun, Sister Moon poster

Brother Sun, Sister Moon

BBC: Are nuns normal? »

A documentary series called "Am I normal?" aired on BBC 2 last year in which a psychologist explored 'normal'. In this particular episode, she tackled religion.

Trustworthy government and prisoners »

In recent times, the House of Commons has come into disrepute.

Sometimes it can be too easy to forget prisoners.